• Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Log In
  • Join
  • Contact Us
  • Instructor Area
    • Teaching Resources
    • Marketing Resources
    • Policies
    • Advanced Certification
    • Advanced Certification Candidate Area
A program of the American Bicycling Education Association
  • 0Shopping Cart
CyclingSavvy
  • Join
    • Savvy Cyclist FREE
    • Savvy Club Rider FREE
    • Ride Awesome!
    • Gift Certificate
  • Learn
    • Articles
    • Street Smarts Booklets
      • Street Smarts Expanded
    • Online Courses
    • Course Comparison
    • Scholarships
    • Gift Certificate
  • Experience
    • Event Calendar
    • In-Person Courses
  • Support Us
    • Our Mission
    • Help Us Grow
    • Fund Scholarships
  • Search
  • Menu Menu
downtown philadelphia bike lane

Pragmatic vs. Dogmatic Bike Lane Use

March 29, 2019/7 Comments/by John Allen

An observation, and a confession:

It’s much easier to shoot video than to edit it.

I use bike lanes.

Backstory

In November 2015 I spent part of a day exploring Philadelphia by bicycle. I shot video of my ride, as I like to do.

I ride with a forward-facing camera on my helmet and a rearward-facing one on the bicycle’s rear rack. The video accompanying this post was recorded on Spruce Street in downtown Philadelphia.

Spruce Street is straight, narrow and one-way, lined with brick row houses. There are a couple of big, old churches. The street has sidewalks on each side and, from left to right, a parking lane, single travel lane and bike lane.

Fast forward two years

In November 2017, 24-year-old cyclist Emily Fredericks died at the corner of 10th and Spruce streets. As she rode on Spruce in the bike lane, a right-turning garbage truck swept over her and she went under its rear wheels.

Then in December, one block from Spruce Street, a truck turned right and ran over Becca Refford, also 24 years old, leaving her seriously injured.

These heartbreaking events

moved me to edit my Spruce Street video and place it online.

Let’s be clear.

I can assure you that I wish this post didn’t have to be written.

I wish Emily and Becca — and every cyclist — knew what I know: How to protect yourself when choosing to use bike lanes.

I want you to understand why what happened to them doesn’t happen to me.

I want you to know how to avoid a catastrophe when you use a bike lane.

Pragmatic vs. Dogmatic Use of Bike Lanes

A cyclist who insists on never using bike lanes is, without question, rigid and dogmatic.

But a cyclist who insists on always using bike lanes is equally rigid and dogmatic.

My use of bike lanes is pragmatic.

I use a bike lane when it works. I get out of it when it doesn’t.

To Use or Not To Use

The bike lane on Spruce Street is entirely reasonable where it does work. The bike lane is next to the curb — parking is only on the other side of the street — so the bike lane doesn’t create a problem with a door zone or blocked sight lines.

I used this bike lane to let motorists pass me when they were faster. The bike lane also let me pass motorists when they were slower. Here’s what’s important:

When I use a bike lane to either release or pass motorists, I do so with caution — and constant observation of what’s happening around me.

Especially when approaching intersections, riding in line with motor vehicles is safer, and often easier.

Traffic Safety is a Dynamic Condition

For much of Spruce Street’s bike lane, sight line obstructions are minimized and there’s no door zone to worry about. But the remaining hazard killed Emily Fredericks and put Becca Refford into a body cast. You can avoid this!

How to Avoid Right-Hook Collisions

Merge left to ride in line with motor traffic. It’s easy to communicate with slow-moving motorists. Look over your shoulder and signal to the driver behind you that you want to take your place in the queue.

In the video you’ll see me take my place in line. I followed our traffic system’s Rules of Movement and passed right-turning vehicles on the left.

Yes, I waited a few seconds longer than some of the cyclists who stayed in the bike lane, but I also could get moving while others were trapped behind right-turning motor vehicles.

No motorists had to wait for me before turning right. So this worked better for the motorists too.

Complain to the Preacher?

I rode Spruce Street on a Sunday morning. In the video, you’ll see worshipers’ cars parked illegally in the bike lane.

I preferred not to get into the middle of a dispute involving politics and religion, so I got into the middle of the travel lane instead, avoiding the door zone on both sides.

Pragmatic, not dogmatic.

It’s easy

to get into a bike lane, once you decide it’s OK to use.

It’s much harder

to get out of a bike lane, once you find yourself in danger.

Tune in again…

for a post about a couple of encounters on Spruce Street that could have turned into real trouble, and how I managed them.

https://cyclingsavvy.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/Spruce-Street-in-downtown-Philly.jpeg 494 498 John Allen https://cyclingsavvy.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/CS-logo_xlong-header.png John Allen2019-03-29 11:00:492019-03-30 13:33:57Pragmatic vs. Dogmatic Bike Lane Use
You might also like
Franklin St Portland ME3-Part Workshop: Portland ME
Aiming for good bicycle lighting
Safe passing -- you can see my hand signal in my shadow.“Control and Release” for safe passing
bike wonkBike Wonk: Ride Like You’re Invisi … Relevant
Franklin St Portland ME3-Part Workshop: Portland ME
spruce street bike lane philadelphiaA Philadelphia Bike Lane Learning Experience
waltham cyclingsavvy classThree Part Course: Waltham MA – May 2020
Join Us at the Philly Bike Expo!
7 replies
  1. Clint Sandusky
    Clint Sandusky says:
    March 29, 2019 at 12:36 PM

    Fantastic reminder John on bike lanes and not letting the “paint” think for you!

    Log in to Reply
  2. Pamela Murray
    Pamela Murray says:
    March 29, 2019 at 2:23 PM

    Excellent, concise and well written. Thank you for writing this. I hope it saves lives.

    Log in to Reply
  3. Gary Madine
    Gary Madine says:
    March 29, 2019 at 4:44 PM

    But all intersections deserve respect. Can a pragmatic cyclist get “right-hooked” in such an intersection while traveling along the “top” of the ‘T’? (I hope you can see it). https://www.google.com/maps/@40.6801744,-75.3508172,42m/data=!3m1!1e3!5m1!1e4?hl=en I almost did. Brodhead Rd is a beautifully surfaced, sparsely trafficked road. Driving westwards (right-to-left) I elected to drive on the shoulder. It’s not a bikelane, but there’s no difference in layout. A motorist overtook. Then that motorist stopped in preparation for a left turn at the intersection that’s visible. Another motorist overtook me. How do readers think that 2nd motorist swung on approach to the 1st motorist? Savvy lesson learned. A similar–but much more complex–sequence of events occurred just yesterday. I made sure yesterday’s second motorist knew I was “in the lane”.

    Log in to Reply
  4. John Allen
    John Allen says:
    March 29, 2019 at 7:00 PM

    Gary, am I correct that there was no place to turn right, but the driver nearly sideswiped you when passing on the right side of the vehicle waiting to turn left? Indeed, I avoided that risk by controlling the bike lane, riding far enough left in it that there would not be room for another vehicle to squeeze in between me and waiting vehicles, and leaving the bike lane to wait in line wherever any slow or stopped driver ahead might merge right. The bike lane on Spruce Street becomes a right-turn lane at the end of blocks where right turns are allowed. Some drivers properly merge into it, others not, as shown in the video.

    Log in to Reply
  5. Marc Caruso
    Marc Caruso says:
    March 30, 2019 at 1:42 AM

    Great article. Some updates since the Fredericks fatality – in February of this year, charges were brought against the dump-truck driver for vehicular homicide. Also the parking wars continue between churchgoers and some cyclists. Just last month I saw an event titled God’s Day of Protest Ride, which as far as I could gather was a group of cyclists planning a ride to yell at churchgoers and non-churchgoers who park in bike lanes on Sundays.

    Log in to Reply
  6. John Schubert
    John Schubert says:
    March 30, 2019 at 12:11 PM

    Another way of saying this: Ignore the “special” paint and pretend it isn’t there. Ride where it best suits. Sometimes it’s the left lane, sometimes it’s the right lane. That labeling of one lane as “special, just for you,” is where the problems begin.

    Log in to Reply
  7. Gary Cziko
    Gary Cziko says:
    April 22, 2019 at 1:46 PM

    Great post and video, John.

    I happen to be dealing with a group bicycling issue where the pragmatic-dogmatic distinction is just what I need to help make my point. So this was especially timely for me!

    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Get Smart!

Brand new edition! John Allen has updated his best-selling Bicycling Street Smarts to incorporate best practices for easy bicycling — wherever you ride!

Get Print Books Here

Now available in full color Kindle Edition!

Buy eBook on Amazon

Scholarship Fund

$6,310 of $10,000 raised

Donate Here

CyclingSavvy is a program of the American Bicycling Education Association. Our mission is to provide programs and resources for the education of bicyclists as drivers of vehicles, and bicycling-related education for traffic engineers, transportation planners, law enforcement professionals, educators, and the general public.

Help Us Grow!

© Copyright - American Bicycling Education Association
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Accessibility
  • Contact Us
  • Instructor Area
  • Advanced Certification Candidate Area
Jim Dodson Interviews Keri CaffreyThe Zaveruha Doctrine of Responsibility
Scroll to top